HSA vs. 401k: Maximize Your Employees' Benefits
The article explains how combining Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) with traditional retirement plans like 401(k)s can significantly enhance employee benefits by leveraging the HSA's triple-tax advantages—tax-deductible contributions, tax-free investment growth, and tax-free withdrawals for qualified medical expenses—while highlighting the growing adoption of HSAs alongside high-deductible health plans to maximize employee retirement savings and healthcare cost management.
Did you know that there is a rising trend within workforce benefits that includes supplementing traditional employee retirement options such as 401k, 403(b), SEP, and more with a Health Savings Account (HSA)? According to Fidelity Investment Research, an HSA can add an additional $119,000 in retirement savings for employees. However, many employers and employees still do not understand the benefits of this triple-tax advantage savings plan. Let’s discuss HSA vs 401k and how you can use the two together to maximize employee happiness, well-being, and retirement.
HSA vs 401k Benefits
An HSA combined with a retirement account, such as a traditional 401k, can offer an array of benefits to enrollees who utilize the pairing.
What is an HSA?
Combined with a High-Deductible Healthcare Plan (HDHP), an HSA enables enrollees to set aside money on a pre-tax basis in a special account to pay for approved healthcare costs. HSAs offer a triple-tax advantage savings plan:
- Employee contributions are tax-deductible, or if submitted through a payroll deduction, are pre-tax
- Investments made by employees can potentially grow tax-free
- Cash withdrawals are tax-free for qualified medical expenses
An HSA offers enrollees the funds they can use to pay deductibles, coinsurance, copayments, medications, and out-of-network provider visits for qualified medical, dental, and vision requirements.
Under law, enrollees in an HDHP are protected for their maximum out-of-pocket expenses. A lot of people confuse an HSA and Flexible Spending Account (FSA). The biggest difference is that an FSA is a use-it-or-lose-it account, while an HSA rolls over year-over-year and is your money forever.
Growth in Adoption of HSAs
According to a 2018 report from Fidelity investments, they added 117 new employers to their HDHP/HSA plans—an increase of 50 percent from 2017. When employers offer HSA-eligible plans, 46 percent of workers add it to their plans.
Even with the increase in enrollments, one of the largest hurdles to overcome is basic education on what these types of plans can do for employees and their dependents. There’s still a lot of work that needs to be done to showcase what an HSA can do. It’s important to help employees plan for the short and long-term.
How it Benefits Employees
The benefits for employees who enroll in HDHP and HSA plans include:
- Federal Income Tax Deduction
- State Income Tax Deduction
- Payroll tax avoidance through either employer contributions or employee deferral through a Section 125 plan
- Tax-deferred earnings growth
- Cash withdrawals are tax-free for qualified expenses
- Cash rolls over year-over-year
- Greater liquidity options—ability to move money for investments and keep accounts insured
- Can contribute to account during retirement
- Other people can contribute to your fund
- After the age of 65, enrollees can withdraw from their HSA to pay for expenses that are non-medical related, penalty free
How it Benefits Employers
The benefits for employers who offer an HDHP and HSA include:
- With deductions straight from payroll, contributions to HSA are pre-taxed, which helps save employers money to use to offset HSA administration costs
- HDHPs, combined with HSAs, are usually less expensive than most other group healthcare plans
- After setup, there is not much support needed by the employer. Employees oversee the management of their accounts and available cash
- Employee well-being and production improve with stronger healthcare coverage
- Employer brand grows as employees are happy and feel secure, directly affecting your ability to attain and retain top talent
Supplementing 401ks with HSAs
As the tax advantages of HSAs are becoming more realized, enrollees are increasingly using these advantages to support their retirement savings. For those 65 and older, you can withdraw funds to pay for non-medical related expenses, penalty free. Taxes may still be applicable like Traditional IRAs, but you will avoid a 20 percent penalty from the IRS.
Combined with a traditional retirement account, like a 401(k), enrollees have a chance to save an additional $119,000 for their retirement with an HSA.
The withdrawal of funds that are not medical-eligible, pre-65-years-old, puts enrollees at risk to pay taxes on the withdrawn amount. Additionally, the IRS may add an extra 20 percent as well.
The Arcoro Platform
The benefits management process is always ongoing. Whether you’re preparing and overseeing the Open Enrollment process, or if you’re updating your data for any life changes, there are many workflows that need to be accounted for.
If you’re relying on manual processes, or a tool with limited capability, you will be at risk for various negative outcomes including:
- Data errors due to human error and manual inefficiencies that can affect employee benefit selections as well as payroll deductions
- Disruptions that affect coverage for employees and their dependents
- Workforce churn due to unhappiness and confusion regarding benefits
- Employee turnover affects processes, production, and sales
The Arcoro Benefits Management module automates key workflows within your benefits administration duties. This helps to prevent user error and keeps your data clean and true. Its built-in integration to over 300 partners allows for seamless connections with top carriers, payroll providers, ERP systems, business intelligence tools, HRIS, and more.
This allows you to scale your technology easily as your requirements call for you to do so.
The full cloud-based Arcoro platform
Aside from Benefits Management, Arcoro features modular functionality with the following automated tools:
- Core HR—featuring employee self-service tools
- Benefits Management
- ACA Compliance
- Time and Attendance
- Payroll Processing
- Applicant Tracking System
- Onboarding
- Performance Management
- Learning Management
- Succession Planning
All these tools can be used to support the security, management, and transmission of your high-compliance data throughout the Arcoro platform, or with integrated third-party partners.
Related
Why HR Benefits Management Software is Essential for Modern Business
HR benefits management software is essential for modern businesses because it streamlines complex, error-prone, and time-consuming manual processes—such as data entry, compliance tracking, and employee communication—by digitizing benefits administration, thereby reducing HR workload, minimizing mistakes, ensuring regulatory compliance, and improving employee access to benefits information.
Why You Need to Offer Voluntary Employee Benefits
The article explains that in a competitive talent market, employers can attract and retain top candidates by offering voluntary employee benefits—such as pet insurance—as supplements to traditional benefits packages, which not only fill coverage gaps but also provide a strategic advantage and a compelling "wow" factor during recruitment, often with the help of brokers to tailor these offerings effectively.
Top Features of Benefits Management Software
Benefits management software streamlines the costly and complex benefits administration process by offering cloud-based automation with key features such as built-in payroll integration for enhanced efficiency and accuracy, customizable workflows for HR administrators, compliance navigation, self-service tools for employees, and scalability to support evolving business needs, ultimately improving employer branding, recruitment, and retention.
Creating a Seamless Employee Benefits Experience with Arcoro and Sage
The article emphasizes the importance of creating a seamless employee benefits experience by using integrated HR software like Arcoro and Sage, which streamlines benefits administration, enhances employee transparency and engagement, and helps construction companies address workforce challenges such as hiring difficulties, retention, and productivity by reducing manual processes and aligning benefits management with existing financial and payroll systems.
HR Management
Arcoro’s Construction HRIS software centralizes employee data, automates HR workflows, ensures compliance with complex construction regulations, connects field and office teams through self-service access, integrates with ERP and payroll systems, and provides analytics for better decision-making, as demonstrated by a case study where an East Coast contractor saved 24,000 annual payroll processing hours and improved HR efficiency.
Onboarding Sets New Hires Up for Success
The article emphasizes that in a competitive job market with low unemployment and frequent career changes, a well-structured onboarding process is essential for employers to effectively integrate new hires by introducing them to company culture, goals, and necessary tools, thereby increasing employee retention, reducing hiring costs, and enhancing performance during the critical initial 90-day period.