Independent Contractors – What’s The New Rule?
On January 9, 2024, the Department of Labor issued a final rule under the Fair Labor Standards Act establishing a new six-factor test—considering profit opportunity, investments, relationship permanence, employer control, work integralness, and worker skill or initiative—to determine whether a worker is an independent contractor or employee, impacting wage, overtime, legal protections, and tax obligations.
On January 9, 2024, the Department of Labor (DOL) published a final rule defining “independent contractor” for the purposes of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).
The DOL issued a new six-factor test for determining whether a worker should be classified as an employee or an independent contractor.
Why should you pay attention to these changes? The difference between an employee and an independent contractor is important under the FLSA because:
- Independent contractors are not subject to the minimum wage or overtime requirements
- Independent contractors are not subject to a number of federal and state laws that cover employees
- Taxation is different for employees vs. independent contractors
The FLSA and other state and federal laws incentivize employers to call a worker an “independent contractor” to avoid the FLSA, taxation, and other rules. The question is: is your worker legally an independent contractor?
Prior to this recent DOL publication, “independent contractor” was defined by a 2021 rule that focused primarily on the principal’s right to control and the worker’s ability to realize a profit or loss. If the factors conflicted, the rule required consideration of the worker’s special skills, the length or permanence of the relationship, and the worker’s integration into the principal’s business.
DOL’s New Rule Defined
The six new factors that will be considered in determining the relationship and the principal are:
- 1.The worker’s opportunity for profit or loss
- 2.Investments by the worker and the potential employer
- 3.The degree of permanence of the relationship
- 4.The nature and degree of the potential employer’s control over the work
- 5.The extent to which the work is integral to the potential employer’s business
- 6.The worker’s skill or initiative
The new rule takes a “totality of the circumstances approach” should two factors strongly oppose each other, and incidental factors are used to contribute to a fully formed definition of the relationship.
The Impact of DOL’s New Rule
This new rule and six-factor test will be critical in industries such as construction, landscaping, and other similar businesses which may be seasonal in nature and require workers to bring their own skills and equipment. Under the new test, workers in these industries who have been treated as independent contractors for years will need to be reclassified to meet the DOL’s rule.
As the government goes through and audits contractors and the workers who were “independent,” the examples of these rules and precedence of lawsuits related to these rules will bring more clarity. For now, things like “the worker’s opportunity for profit and loss” is likely to mean: does the worker have their own organized business, registered as a corporation or single member LLC, and file the federal and state government tax forms making sure they are paying the employer and employee portions of Medicare and FICA taxes, something independent contractors must do when not classified as a W-2 employee. Related to this rule is the third rule – “investments by the worker” – meaning does the worker have their own equipment, trucks, and other tools that are not provided by the employer, but instead are owned and kept by the independent contractor, showing the worker is not as reliant on the employer as a W-2 employee would be.
Other examples of the applicability of the new rules will include looking at the contracts the employer and worker sign. If they sign a small, one-activity construction project, they are more likely to still be considered “independent,” versus a long-term, or “open-ended” contract, which acts more as an “at-will” employment contract – looking more like a W-2 employee under the new rules.
Many employees in the construction industry, from subcontractors working on building, electrical, plumbing, which have “always” been “independent contractors” may soon see W-2s instead of 1099s, as their investments in the success of the business is reevaluated and the integration of their work in the actual business function of the potential employer is reassessed.
Big changes may be coming for your business under this rule, but Arcoro customers can take advantage of our partnership with myHRcounsel™ that provides legally backed answers to HR/employment and compliance questions from experienced employment attorneys, in all 50 states. Using myHRcounsel’s online portal and mobile app, answers are generally available in two hours or less.
Contact us to learn more about Arcoro and myHRcounsel and how we can help you avoid potential compliance issues in classifying your construction workforce.
Related
What Does Paid in Arrears Mean?
Paid in arrears refers to the practice of making payments after services or work have been completed, commonly used in construction and payroll to manage cash flow by delaying payment until after the work period or project completion, thereby allowing businesses to maintain operational liquidity.
Timesheet Fraud: Causes, Consequences and Prevention Tips
Timesheet fraud in the construction industry involves employees falsifying work hours through practices like padding timesheets, buddy punching, abusing overtime, and falsifying locations, leading to significant financial and compliance risks for companies, which can be mitigated by using automated time-tracking solutions such as Arcoro's ExakTime.
How Flexible Payroll Systems Help You Adapt to Shifting Labor Laws
The article explains how flexible payroll systems tailored for construction help companies comply with over 180 changing federal and state labor laws—particularly regarding complex wage regulations and worker classification—to avoid costly penalties by ensuring accurate payroll management across multiple job sites and worker types.
Most Common Pay Periods
The article explains that choosing the best payroll schedule—weekly, biweekly, semimonthly, or monthly—depends on factors like employee payment preferences, the mix of salaried versus hourly staff, processing costs, and state labor laws, with weekly payroll benefiting hourly workers by providing frequent pay and easier overtime tracking, while other schedules offer different advantages and trade-offs for businesses and employees.
Why Digital Time Tracking Beats Manual Time Cards for Construction
The article explains that manual time tracking in construction leads to costly payroll errors, illegible handwriting issues, and compliance problems, while digital time clock apps streamline the process, improve accuracy, reduce administrative burdens, and prevent employee dissatisfaction caused by paycheck mistakes.
Almost Half of States Require Them: How to Easily Account for Meals and Breaks
Nearly half of U.S. states mandate meal and rest breaks, which are crucial for employee productivity and satisfaction, but since the federal government does not require them, employers must carefully track break times—especially as short rest breaks (5-20 minutes) count as compensable work hours under the Fair Labor Standards Act, while meal breaks (typically 30 minutes) are unpaid only if employees are fully relieved from duty—making accurate timekeeping essential to comply with varying state laws and avoid payroll complications.